jump to navigation

On Being Critical January 13, 2009

Posted by Mark T. Market in Reflections.
Tags: , , , ,
4 comments

I’ve been spending a great deal of my blogging time on the critical thinker and this was deliberate for me: I needed a venue to ask questions, or more appropriately a venue to learn how to ask questions.

Opening that blog with rickyM, aratron, and receiving feedback and comments from friends and bloggers all over was a welcome experience, since it allowed me to openly explore areas of inquiry I never consciously considered–although many questions have been perennially on the table for me (appearing on an occasional coffee chat, lunch musings, dinner talk, etc.). The fantastic thing for me as a result of this deliberate blogging is that it felt refreshing, almost cathartic, to have those thoughts laid down in a formal manner for other people to see and criticize.

One unexpected benefit of the critical thinker experience is that it had put me in touch with many people who also consider themselves “truth-seekers” and were looking for kindred souls and intellects who not only had the capacity to understand the questions they were (albeit haphazardly) formulating, but had the spiritual fortitude to go ahead and ask them especially when traditional sentiment favored silence.

I was not born a critical thinker, but now having experienced it briefly, I think I was born to be one (and caveat: that it will always be a work in progress).

Which brings me to the more poignant note.

Ever since starting that critical thinker site, I’ve been more and more active in scientific, religious, and philosophical discussions with many parties. One concrete example in particular is a regular study group I’ve been attending with rickyM every week which started out as a book review of ricky’s book: The Force, but has grown to be a forum not only for religion but for critical thinking in general.

I’ve been meeting that group for well into several months now and the discussions have been very varied and entertaining–we simply don’t focus on one topic but allow our minds the freedom to probe and expand in any direction. Just to give a flavor, some of the questions and topics we’ve touched on:

  • Does God evolve?
  • The myth of the given
  • Is unconditional love absolute?
  • What are absolutes?
  • History of theism/God
  • Astrotheology and conspiracy theories
  • Evolution of consciousness

I don’t plan to elaborate on these topics in this post, but only to show the extreme lengths the discussions have taken–and the list is not by any means exhaustive at this point!

One thing the study group has helped leverage for me is that the amount of material between rickyM and myself, the critical thinker blogs, and the videos and documents even on this personal blog have been put to excellent use as research material for the discussions–and I think we’ve only begun to scratch the surface in terms of the kinds of discussions we would like to take. I helped introduce the group to the Zeitgeist videos which were very eye-opening for them, and those represent only 2 of the list of videos I’ve already accumulated on image therapy–clearly a long road full of insights ahead.

And where does this put me? Well even if the amount of research is already piling, I consider this point to only be the beginning of the journey–which is for all intents and purposes a spiritual journey for me. Actually there is another line of thought that logically follows this brief flashback but I’ll save that for the next post–specifically that my foray into the critical thinking blog has just helped set the stage: by providing me with an excellent framework to approach issues, linking me up with like-minded people, and encouraging me to pursue lines of thought I previously never conceived or simply ignored. But a stage is only a stage and the real action is: now that I am learning to think, it will eventually beg the next question, What Do I Want To Think? and more importantly: What Do I Want To Believe?

Like the process of developing a critical mind and approach, adopting a philosophy can’t (and shouldn’t) happen overnight and without due deliberation. In the next post I’m going to try to make furtive steps in that direction.

Time to finally make a stand.

The Four Horsemen – A Roundtable Discussion August 24, 2008

Posted by Mark T. Market in Quotables.
Tags: , , , , , , ,
add a comment

On the 30th of September 2007, Richard Dawkins, Daniel Dennett, Sam Harris and Christopher Hitchens sat down for a first-of-its-kind, unmoderated 2-hour discussion, convened by RDFRS and filmed by Josh Timonen.

All four authors have recently received a large amount of media attention for their writings against religion – some positive, and some negative. In this conversation the group trades stories of the public’s reaction to their recent books, their unexpected successes, criticisms and common misrepresentations. They discuss the tough questions about religion that face to world today, and propose new strategies for going forward.

Check out this enlightening discussion here.

Presence of Evidence, Evidence of Presence August 21, 2008

Posted by Mark T. Market in The List.
Tags: , ,
add a comment

In hindsight, one of the craziest things by the standards of my present life that I recall having done was reading the bible cover to cover–like one would do a novel, or a text book. I did it when I was twelve. I was not encouraged to do it–not by my parents (who ironically were yet to evolve into the religious churchgoers they are now)–and definitely not by my school (reading the entirety of the Old and New Testament along with some books of the Apocrypha were a little beyond the requirement for elementary-level sunday school).

Crazy. But admittedly one of the best things I’ve ever done for my mental health.

You see reading what I can describe as THE most taken-for-granted book of our age at such a young age made me see early on, without the benefit of extensive catechism or religious indoctrination, the nature of the bible as a literary work–as essentially a book, or collection of books strung together. I saw at an early age, that the bible repeats stories across books, repeats characters. But more importantly, I saw with my fresh eyes and fresh mind–unfettered by adult supervision or guidance–that the bible often did not agree with itself, and to my young mind, this was very confusing.

I now know that the various books of the bible were written at different times, by different people, for likely very different purposes. And stringing together these diverse works will definitely result in some conflict of ideas.

Take the most important (to Christians at least) books in the New Testament: The Gospels. For your average educated Christian, mention the term “gospel” and immediately they know you are referring to four books: The Gospels according to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John. For most educated Christians, this is where it ends. However, there’s a curious phrase mentioned by Luke, in his letter to Theophilus in the introduction to Luke’s gospel:

 1Many have undertaken to draw up an account of the things that have been fulfilled[a] among us, 2just as they were handed down to us by those who from the first were eyewitnesses and servants of the word. 3Therefore, since I myself have carefully investigated everything from the beginning, it seemed good also to me to write an orderly account for you, most excellent Theophilus, 4so that you may know the certainty of the things you have been taught.

Many? Did he just mean the four gospels? Or more?

As it turns out, there were more. Actually, there were at least twenty gospels by some accounts–and they all didn’t necessarily agree with each other.

As part of my own research, I came upon work by an Anglican priest: Peter Owen Jones–who made a public uncovering of the nature of the other gospels that were not accepted into the canonical New Testament. This is because some of these other gospels have radically different versions of Jesus than mainstream Christianity has been told to accept. From his documentary:

If the gospel of Peter had won out, Christians today might believe that Jesus never died. If the gospel of Phillip had won, Mary Magdalene might have been hailed as the first pope.

- Peter Owen Jones

Check out Jones’s work here.

The Tsunami and the Problem of Evil August 18, 2008

Posted by Mark T. Market in Quotables.
Tags: , ,
add a comment

Rev. Tom Honey, vicar of the Church of England grapples with the concept of an almighty, all-knowing God, and dramatic and horrific events such as the South Asian tsunami in 2004. It is a wonderful stance: touching and brave at the same time. And it encourages all of us to dig deeper into the truth of our existence.

Technology, Faith, and Human Shortcomings August 18, 2008

Posted by Mark T. Market in Quotables.
Tags: , , ,
add a comment

Famous preacher Rev. Billy Graham shares his thoughts on the fate of the world, and his marvel at the power of technology to improve human life. He shares wonderful insights about the end of evil, suffering and death only after acceptance of Christ and his message.

Wonderful talk.

Militant Atheism August 18, 2008

Posted by Mark T. Market in Quotables.
Tags: , , , , , ,
3 comments

Professor and Evolutionist, Richard Dawkins, author of The God Delusion makes an appeal during the TED conference for atheists to speak up and cease being respectful of religion–as notably Christian religious lobbyists have always remained disrespectful of both atheists and other religions.

It is an impassioned and eloquent speech, that also raises some interesting and crucial points about the status of religion in our society today.

Living A Purpose August 17, 2008

Posted by Mark T. Market in Quotables.
Tags: , , , , , , ,
add a comment

Finding the meaning of life is a life changing experience. And in truth, it goes beyond religion. Here’s Rick Warren talking in TED about living a life of purpose.

Rick Warren is a pastor, philanthropist, and the author of the bestselling book The Purpose Driven Life. He made a lot of money when his book became very popular, and Rick shares in this talk how his reflection on life was changed by tremendous wealth, affluence, and attention. He relates this to his search to the antidote of spiritual emptiness.

Good talk for everyone looking for the meaning of life.

Zeitgeist Refuted August 16, 2008

Posted by Mark T. Market in Quotables.
Tags: ,
2 comments

After the movie Zeitgeist criticized Christian and religious belief as a radical misinterpretation of astrotheological allegory, many people (notably Christians) have reacted strongly against it. Check out this video.

Religion as an Idea August 16, 2008

Posted by Mark T. Market in Quotables.
Tags: , ,
1 comment so far

A follow-up on my previous post on the gospels–which was a part of a longer documentary made by Brian Fleming.

Here’s the trailer to give you a flavor.

The video raises some critical questions about beliefs taken for granted.

I’ve added the film under Image Therapy. Check it out here.

Jordan Maxwell on the Occult, Theology, Conspiracies August 3, 2008

Posted by Mark T. Market in Quotables.
Tags: , , , ,
2 comments

Jordan Maxwell is a famous researcher on controversial topics, conspiracy theories, theology and the occult.

I posted a film of Maxwell’s where he discusses these topics to satisfy your curiosity and hunger for the answers to controversial questions.

Before Zeitgeist, before Esoteric Agenda, before The Ultimate Con, there was Jordan Maxwell.

Check it out on Image Therapy here.